Swastika Sparks Debate | Controversial Symbol in Hermetic Tarot
A growing conversation among tarot enthusiasts is focusing on the swastika incorporated in the Star of David design within the Hermetic Tarot cards. This imagery, featured on cards like the 6 and 4 of Pentacles, has raised many questions about the artist's intent and its implications, particularly given its release just 33 years after the Holocaust.
The Hermetic Tarot, created by Godfrey Dowson and published by US Games in 1978, heavily references Jewish mysticism including Kabbalah and angel names from the Book of Enoch. However, the presence of a symbol often associated with hate has reignited debate over its appropriateness in modern tarot interpretations. Some people believe the swastika's use represents a complex intertwining of cultural symbols, while others decry it as deeply offensive.
This dialogue intensified recently, with many voices suggesting that the swastika's roots in various cultures, historically linked to good luck and prosperity, have been overshadowed by modern associations. Recently, one commenter stated, "There are swastikas on buildings in NYC. They were built before the right-facing swastika became associated with Nazism." Another remarked on the potential for spiritual power, saying, "Power itself is neutral; it's how it's wielded that defines its impact." A third user further pointed out the positional differences between variations of the symbol, raising concerns about historical interpretation.
Key Themes from Recent Discussions
Cultural Hijacking: Many people argue that the symbolism is appropriated and misrepresented, leading to offensive interpretations. A commenter mentioned, "People see 4 sticks and assume hatred when they've been taught the same history lesson their entire lives."
Historical Context: Discussions around the swastika and its rich heritage continue to evolve, contrasting with its current associations. One participant noted, "The Star of David is a 2D view of a Merkaba the combination suggests that movement/rotation to me."
Fascism in the Occult: Some comments emphasized the historical connections between occult practices and fascist ideologies, stirring concern among commenters.
"The whole occult world crawls with fascists like roaches," one user expressed.
Interestingly, some suggest that the symbolism, while alarming, may not have been intended to convey a hateful message. "I don't think this swastika is meant to be Nazi adjacent, but it sure took me by surprise," stated a respondent. Others disagree, asserting its existence on tarot cards tied to financial themes can evoke antisemitic perspectives.
Community Responses Reflecting Sentiments
"The dirty truth about Hermeticism is that it’s entangled with a significant fascist constituency."
"The popularity of Hermeticism with Nazis was not an accident."
This complex conversation continues with tarot enthusiasts trying to navigate the challenging landscape of symbolism in their practice. Can the original meanings associated with such symbols ever be fully reclaimed?
Insights and Summaries
⚡ 33 years post-Holocaust, the swastika evokes strong emotions.
🚩 Community members highlight its intersection with the occult and its historical misuse.
⚠️ "The timing seems critical, especially with the tarot exhibition coming up."
As discussions progress, tarot enthusiasts are actively seeking to clarify the connection between ancient symbols and modern interpretation while confronting the enduring impact of cultural appropriation.