Hugh Newman Sparks Debate | Is Stone Melting a Real Technique?
A growing discussion surrounds Hugh Newman’s claims about a technique he calls "stone melting" at Gobekli Tepe. This theory has ignited significant debate among experts and people, raising questions on how ancient societies built their megalithic structures.
Fresh Perspectives on the Controversy
Newman's assertions have prompted a range of opinions across various forums:
Erosion vs. Alternative Theories: Many defend erosion as a more plausible explanation, with one commenter stating, "It’s called erosion. What an asshat." Others jokingly suggest extraterrestrial influences, with comments like, "Is that what the aliens from Eros do when they’re not"
Geothermal Springs and Natural Shaping: A significant comment points to nearby geothermal springs with acidic water as a possible natural force shaping stones. This theory supports the notion that ancient builders might have used accessible resources for construction.
Technical Credibility Concern: Doubts linger about the legitimacy of stone melting as a method. A skeptic remarked that Newman seems lacking in geological and engineering backgrounds, referring to the necessity of solid credentials to analyze such claims.
Community Reactions
The conversation mixes humor with serious inquiry. One participant noted, "Wow a lot of people do not believe stone melting is a thing. It is very much a thing!" Some found humor in the debate with comments like, "Perfect use of this lmao," indicating a playful response to serious claims.
A fresh comment brought up an interesting point about using a Fresnel lens to concentrate sunlight for stone shaping. This adds another layer to the ongoing discussions about ancient technologies and potential methodologies.
"Seems to be a bit out of his depth - no Geology, Engineering, Archaeology, BA Hons in Film and Journalism."
Key Points
🔍 Claims of stone melting challenge traditional theories of ancient construction.
💧 The influence of geothermal springs raises questions about historical building techniques.
😂 Commentary mixes skepticism with humor, showcasing diverse community reactions.
As the debate continues, there's an underlying excitement about what Newman's claims could reveal about ancient engineering techniques. Will this lead to fresh insights into the practices of our ancestors?