Kadampa Controversy? | Growing Alarms Over New Kadampa Tradition
Growing Distrust Among Followers
A growing coalition of people is pushing back against the New Kadampa Tradition, raising alarms about its practices and teachings. Recently, a surge of comments from various individuals, including former members, have revealed serious concerns regarding the group’s conduct and its disconnect from mainstream Tibetan Buddhism.
Voices of Concern
One commenter expressed strong sentiments about the tradition, referring to it as a cult, with many former members sharing similar narratives. They noted that the New Kadampa Tradition is not aligned with major Tibetan Buddhist schools and actively opposes the wishes of the Dalai Lama.
Another commenter shared their experience at a meditation center in Oslo, Norway, describing it as generally positive but noting the expectation of payment for monk-led sessions. Despite their complaints about how the organization operates, they acknowledged the project focused on meditation with no coercion.
"I find it hard to believe that everyone connected to Kadampa is 'bad,'" they said, highlighting the complexities surrounding the faction.
Critics voiced concerns over the worship of Dorje Shugden, describing it as problematic. One user cautioned about mental disturbances linked to joining the group, emphasizing the need to steer clear of traditions deeply involved with controversial figures.
Interestingly, not all comments were negative. Some individuals reported positive personal growth from their experiences in the New Kadampa Tradition
"I've gained insight from their teachings and feel no one's controlling me," noted a supporter.
Mixed Sentiments
Despite the alarming critiques, the comment section displays a split sentiment. Key quotes include:
"Stay away!" - A concerned family member.
"Everything seemed normal. No one pushed anyone." - A balanced perspective from a neutral participant.
Key Themes Emerging
Control: Many warn of perceived manipulation and the discouragement of exploring Buddhist texts beyond their teachings.
Isolation: Critics argue the organization does not connect with mainstream Buddhist communities, isolating itself.
Path to Understanding: Supporters believe in the personal benefits gained from the teachings offered, stressing the individual’s journey.
Essential Insights
⚠️ A significant number view the New Kadampa Tradition as a cult, noting its divergence from established practices.
🌟 Supporters find personal growth within its framework despite negative portrayals.
❗️ The comments raise questions about the authenticity and integrity of groups operating under controversial doctrines.
The conversation could lead many to reconsider their affiliations with this tradition. With growing scrutiny, the future of the New Kadampa Tradition remains uncertain. Will it reform to align itself more closely with accepted teachings, or continue down a contentious path? The outcomes may reveal much about the evolving relationship between followers and their spiritual communities.