Where Is Hell? | Bodhisattva Vow Sparks New Debate
A growing conversation among people tackles the existence of hell and heaven in Buddhist beliefs, igniting interest in the bodhisattva vow. As doubts emerge about traditional afterlife realms, the question arises: can one take the bodhisattva vow without believing in heaven or hell?
Context of the Discussion
This debate springs from a post questioning the validity of taking the vow without belief in hell. The poster mentions that if hell exists, it might be in an astral plane.
Key Insights from Comments
Zen Perspective: A user offered a Zen parable illustrating that heaven and hell are states of mind rather than physical places. The monk highlights that anger is hell, while humility is heaven.
Cosmological Understanding: Many users suggest that spiritual realms exist within the mind. One noted, "Everything is in the mind and the mind is not to be found." Several others agree, arguing that consciousness defines one's perception of these realms.
Spiritual Growth: Comments reflect that taking the bodhisattva vow can enhance spiritual practice, showing that commitment matters more than beliefs about heaven and hell. "Yes, take the vow if you have the aspiration to become enlightened for the sake of all beings," a contributor advised.
"The mind is its own place and in itself can make a heaven of hell and a hell of heaven." - Milton
Sentiment Patterns
The feedback shows a mix of curiosity and support. Many express encouragement for those exploring their spiritual beliefs, emphasizing the positive impact of the bodhisattva vow.
Key Takeaways
△ Heaven and Hell are subjective experiences rooted in personal consciousness.
▽ Zen Teachings like the parable illustrate that emotional states shape perceptions of reality.
※ "With prayer wheel and Chen rezig practice, I've learned this" - Insight from a community member.
This ongoing inquiry continues to spark discussions, challenging and inspiring exploration of belief systems and individual spiritual journeys.