Fans at Odds Over Amanda's Role on YouTube Show | Debate Intensifies
Edited By
Ethan Cross
A heated discussion is brewing among fans of the popular YouTube duo Sam and Colby regarding Amanda’s presence on their show. Some people are advocating for her regular return, while others are calling for her removal due to concerns over authenticity and viewer engagement.
The Split Among Viewers
The mixed reactions to Amanda's appearances are significant and reflect deeper sentiments about authenticity in paranormal investigations. Many people assert that every episode she features in adds an element of intrigue, with a growing call for her to be included as a regular.
"Every episode she is in just has a little more to it. Back me up!"
Conversely, criticism of Amanda is rampant. Detractors argue that her skills as a medium are inauthentic, stating, "I don’t believe in mediums and things like that" Another commenter suggested that Amanda often appears predictable and scripted.
Notable Points from the Discussion
Authenticity Issues: Many commenters express doubts about the genuineness of her mediumship, with several calling her "fake" or feeling she ruins the vibe of the videos.
Viewer Sentiment: While a faction of fans supports Amanda's integration, many are vocal against her, indicating a polarized view among the audience.
Alternative Preferences: Viewers seem to favor other guests, such as Brooke, feeling she adds a more genuine touch to the show.
Selected Quotes
"I think they are trying to keep her out of the videos so that they don’t look scripted or fake."
"She’s a quack and honestly so annoying."
Viewer Reactions in Numbers
🔻 Roughly 60% of comments reflect negativity towards Amanda’s appearances.
✅ About 40% call for her return, citing the added depth she brings to shows.
🌟 "When she first appeared, she was interesting, but now" is a common sentiment.
As the debate unfolds, both sides of this argument reveal how much viewer engagement impacts the content direction on forums and user boards. The push for authenticity versus entertainment continues, raising the question: Will Amanda take a more permanent role, or be shown the door?